This post is the fifth in a seven-part series unpacking the 2023 Cardus Education Survey. If you’re just joining the series, here’s a look at what we’ve covered so far:
Series Overview: Exploring the 2023 Cardus Education Survey
Part 1 — Introduction to the Study: What Difference Does Christian Education Make?
Part 2 — What Students Remember: The Christian High School Experience
Part 3 — Learning, Earning, and Serving: Long-Term Outcomes of Christian Education
Part 4 — Shaping Citizens: Civic Formation and Christian Education
→ Part 5 — Christian School Graduates: Mental Health and Well-Being (this post)
Part 6 — Faith and Family Formation
Part 7 — Reflections, Areas for Growth, and Next Steps
—
Conversations about student well-being have become front and center in education—especially in the wake of COVID-19. Mental health, once treated as peripheral to academic life, is now recognized as foundational to a young person’s ability to learn, relate, and thrive long-term. The 2023 Cardus Education Survey (CES) affirms this shift by including, for the first time, a series of measures related to mental health and overall well-being.
These new metrics go beyond mood or momentary emotions. They explore life satisfaction, anxiety and depression, optimism about the future, and the strength of social relationships. Together, they help paint a broader picture of how graduates are doing—not just in their careers or communities, but in their inner lives.
Let’s take a closer look at three dimensions of mental health and well-being from the CES data: life satisfaction, emotional health, and relationships.
Life Satisfaction
When asked how satisfied they are with life overall, adults who attended Protestant and Catholic schools report the highest average scores—slightly above their peers from public and nonreligious independent schools.
The survey used a standard five-question scale, measuring responses like “In most ways, my life is close to my ideal” and “If I could live my life over, I would change almost nothing.” On a 6-point scale, public school graduates averaged 3.99.
According to Figure 5.1, Protestant and Catholic school graduates scored slightly higher with their statisfaction with life, but the differences disappear after accounting for background factors like family income or parental education.
Still, the presence of those higher scores among faith-based graduates is worth noting. Satisfaction with life is a meaningful outcome, and it invites us to consider the deeper supports that may be embedded in Christian school culture.
Emotional Health: Depression and Anxiety
On more clinical measures—symptoms related to depression and anxiety—the survey tells a sobering but nuanced story.
Across most school sectors, scores are remarkably similar in Figure 5.2. But one group stands out: homeschool graduates. They reported significantly lower levels of depression and anxiety than all other sectors. On average, their scores were 0.28 points lower than public school graduates—a meaningful difference, especially after controlling for demographics.
This finding raises thoughtful questions about pace of life, stress exposure, and emotional safety during adolescence. While Christian school graduates do not show lower levels overall, it may signal an opportunity to look deeper at how we support the spiritual and mental health in our school environments.
Relational Well-Being: Closeness of Social Relationships
The CES also asked graduates to reflect on their closest relationships—their friendships, sense of community, and confidence in receiving help when needed.
In Figure 5.3, The average score for public school graduates was 4.19 out of 6. Catholic school graduates scored modestly higher, and no statistically significant differences were found for Protestant, independent, or homeschool graduates once background variables were controlled.
Still, the emphasis on belonging is critical. As with so many outcomes in this survey, relational well-being is often shaped by school culture. Mentorship, peer relationships, and healthy communities during high school may carry long-term relational value.
Optimism, Purpose, and Gratitude
Interestingly, homeschool graduates were more likely to agree with this statement in Figure 5.4—14 percentage points more likely than public school graduates. This suggests a complexity: while homeschoolers scored lowest in anxiety and depression, they may face distinct challenges in long-term direction-setting and vocational identity.
In Figure 5.5, Catholic school graduates were the most likely to agree with this statement (6 percentage points more than public school graduates), followed closely by other independent and Protestant school graduates. However, the difference was not statistically significant once background demographics were considered.
Finally, a hopeful note across all sectors: about 75 percent of graduates—regardless of school type—agreed with the statement “When I think about the future, I am positive.” That’s encouraging in a time when cultural narratives often suggest despair is the norm.
Final Thoughts
Mental health is complex, and no single factor—including school type—can fully determine a person’s well-being. But the Cardus Education Survey helps us see patterns and ask better questions.
Christian school graduates appear to experience life satisfaction and relational health at rates comparable to or above national averages, though these gains may be tied more to family context than school itself. At the same time, homeschool graduates stand out for lower anxiety and depression, even while reporting higher uncertainty about purpose and direction.
For Christian educators, these findings offer an invitation:
Do our classrooms and school activities cultivate peace and well-being, or just performance?
Do our students know that being successful in life is a great calling, but is it rooted in being known and loved by Christ?
Are we equipping students with tools to face challenges—not just moral clarity, but also inner resilience and relational support?
And are we, as adults, modeling what it looks like to live joyful, thankful, purpose-filled lives in Christ?
Coming next: Part 6 — Faith and Family Formation







This episode sure prompted me to think a lot more than I thought it would when I first revisited it again this week. I have several thoughts on these categories that answer some of the “Why”, and I appreciate the questions proposed in the Final Thoughts section.:
Life Satisfaction
-World View and Family Expectations are going to influence this the most and if ideals within either were played out as they envisioned they would.
Emotional Health: Depression and Anxiety
Since this involves a lack of Joy (gladness of being with a human) and scanning for threat, it makes sense that homeschool is the least to experience this. Homeschool would have less of these feelings due to a stronger sense of safety during the week, spending more time with a parent who can possibly (if choosing to spend all the days with their children) provide attunement and unconditional love of patience, kindness, protection, hope, trust, perseverance, not self seeking, not rude, endurance through weaknesses, slow to anger and no shaming or record keeping of failures.Due to society health, these are harder to come by in an institutionalized setting.
Close Social Relationships
While peer relationships scored higher than homeschool on this factor, the data indicates that feeling secure is more likely to happen for children/teens when they can spend more time actually together with a loving parent even more so than peers. While everyone can’t homeschool, the more adults can invest meaningful, quality, attuned time with their children, the more they can carry that security into their school day for stronger mental health quality. Students might feel like they have close friends, but can still feel miserable in their depression and anxiety. It’s up to parents and teachers to step up to provide the environment…..and if they can't ... ..we need to address the “why” for us adults, and seriously consider changing something about adult lifestyle and institutional structures.
Optimism, Purpose, Gratitude
While home schoolers indicated that they lack clear goals and sense of purpose, this proves their environment does provide less pressure to decide, prove self, or fabricate a particular outcome overall. This in turn creates less pressure, which in turn effects anxiety and depression. Inversely, in the “So much in life to be thankful for” category, there was a positive metric of “When I think about the future, I am positive”. Yet they have anxiety and depression. This suggests the pressuring and hopeless feelings are environmentally dependent with the possibility that there are aspirations for a better life once they are “grown up” and out of the school environment.
Moving our school environment toward a more loving experience and prioritizing this, will aid in allowing students to enjoy their childhood and the process of living and growing, instead of always only looking forward to the concept that when they are an adult their life will be better somehow. What good is it to gain the world and lose our soul? It's up to adults to model this for children and do more structuring around the relational experience, with less performance based pressure.