This post is the sixth in a seven-part series unpacking the 2023 Cardus Education Survey. If you’re just joining the series, here’s what we’ve covered:
Series Overview: Exploring the 2023 Cardus Education Survey
Part 1 — Introduction to the Study: What Difference Does Christian Education Make?
Part 2 — What Students Remember: The Christian High School Experience
Part 3 — Learning, Earning, and Serving: Long-Term Outcomes of Christian Education
Part 4 — Shaping Citizens: Civic Formation and Christian Education
→ Part 6 — Faith and Family Formation in Christian School Graduates (this post)
Part 7 — Reflections, Areas for Growth, and Next Steps
Christian education isn’t only about preparing students for college or careers—it’s about shaping followers of Christ who carry that formation into every corner of their lives. The 2023 Cardus Education Survey provides a powerful lens into how graduates of Protestant schools are shaped spiritually and how that influence carries into marriage, parenting, and long-term values.
Here are the seven most notable areas where Protestant school graduates stand out.
1. Belief in God or a Higher Power
While just 40% of public school graduates say they “definitely believe” in God, Protestant school graduates are 29 percentage points more likely to say yes. Even after adjusting for background factors, the gap remains a statistically significant 20 points.
2. Weekly Bible Reading
Only 18% of public school graduates report reading the Bible or sacred texts weekly. Protestant graduates are 24 points higher, and even with demographic controls, they remain 16 points more likely to maintain this habit.
3. Feeling God’s Presence Weekly
Do graduates experience God as real and present? Among Protestant school graduates, 39% say they feel God’s presence at least weekly, compared to 30% of public school graduates—a 9-point edge, though just shy of statistical significance.
4. Parents Teach Children About Faith
Protestant school graduates are more likely than any other group to affirm that parents should teach their children about religious beliefs.
5. Marriage as a Valued Institution
Only 35% of public school graduates say marriage is “very important” to them. Protestant school graduates are 14 percentage points more likely to agree.
6. Marriage Status: More Likely to Marry?
While not statistically significant, Protestant school graduates appear more likely to marry and less likely to remain unmarried than their public school peers.
7. Parenthood Rates
In one area, Protestant graduates don’t stand out: rates of having children. They are slightly less likely than public school graduates to report having children, though the difference isn’t statistically meaningful. That said, when paired with Figure 6.8, we see that Protestant graduates may have fewer children—but they do care more deeply about passing on their faith to them.
Final Thoughts on Faith and Family
The data tells a consistent story: Protestant school graduates are more likely to believe in God, engage spiritual disciplines, value marriage, and take seriously their role in raising the next generation in faith.
But it also reminds us: this doesn’t happen by default. It happens through parenting, peer influence, school culture, discipleship, biblical instruction, and adult role models who live what they teach. No doubt social media has a huge influence here on the “good life” that is being constantly presented to students, regardless of religious beliefs.
We may also want to ask, in a changing cultural and spiritual landscape:
Are we preparing students not just to inherit faith—but to own it and live it in a post-Christian world?
Do our graduates know how to engage a culture that often sees traditional family values and Christian beliefs as outdated or intolerant?
And even for those who retain faith, are we equipping them to lead their homes and churches with courage, humility, and conviction?
Coming next: Part 7 — Reflections, Areas for Growth, and Next Steps










The "Feeling God"s Presence Weekly" appears to be the chart upon which all the others would hang (right after the Belief chart). Since a relationship with God through Jesus is an ultimate end with which we would hope students take with them after graduation, it would assist with their application of decisions and aspirations of the others.
Coming from the Catholic tradition as a child, I know that the concept of a personal relationship was not taught.So that might play into the graduates perception of how He is or isn't interacting with their life as adults if there is more of a collective concept of thought dominating, and nuances that Jesus is only found at the church....and even then......at the alter He is still hanging dead on the Cross as depicted by the statue, it seems the visual would effect the imagination to some degree as to how much powerful access we have or not.
Again the homechool bar graph is pretty amazing. Their parents zeal to bring God into their everyday life moments clearly paid off. Perhaps there is more verbal modeling of gratitude, and prayer as the day passes, for which a busy classroom or teacher doesn't make as known to students how that is happening. In my opinion there also is the factor of how much our knowledge of God's interaction with humanity over the whole Bible can help translate that into how we are a continuing story that just is not in a Bible book......but we are still stories of God's children non the less.
Aside from the book of Ruth and Esther being about courageous women, I very much appreciate these books because they are the only books that are character stories and yet God was not an active participant in the narration. It does not even narrate that they even prayed. He was clearly working in their hearts and they believed it was wise to heed the council of their special relative, for their calling. Though they too had no guarantee that anything would work out to their benefit. They just had to keep going with the next best thing they believed was good for them to do. These gals have brought the realities of walking with God to my perception of Him working and speaking in my life but it did start with knowledge of these books and how God moved in spite of narration keeping Him silent. The huge piece of Christian education is to be able to help young people know this God who existed before they were born. Biblical literacy is really needed to help that piece.
While driving home this evening I chose not to listen to anything in the car even knowing it was a 30 min drive. I just didn't feel like listening to anything which is not common. I believe the Lord allowed that feeling so I could hear him better, down the road....literally. While at a stop light, it turned green. I had an unction (I believe was the Lord), saying ".....give in a few seconds....your not in a rush". Then without thinking much about it I just stared at the green light repeating one more time..."your not in a rush". That was about 3 slow seconds. On the 4th second I placed my foot at the pedal...and on the 5th second a car went speeding through the opposite red light....right through the intersection where I would have been if I had not been listening. I would have been T-boned right on my driver's side at a high speed. I was speechless, amazed, and in awe that I was saved. Now...that is God's presence....and I'm so grateful I had wiser people before me teaching me how to listen.